INFLUENCE OF CULTIVAR AND LOCALITY ON THE YIELD TRAITS OF SUGAR BEET, IN 2009

DOI:
UDK:
JOURNAL No:
Volume 35, Issue 4
PAGES
197-200
KEYWORDS
sugar beet, locality, yield, processing quality, cultivar
TOOLS
Print this page
Creative Commons License
Stevan Đ. Radivojević1*, Vlada M. Filipović2,
Marija I. Bodroža-Solarov1, Đorđe N. Glamočlija3
1Institute for Food Technology, Novi Sad, Serbia
2 Institute Tamiš. Novoseljanski put 33. 13000 Pančevo
3 Faculty of Agronomy, Zemun-Belgrade, Nemanjina 6, 11081 Belgrade

ABSTRACT

Abstract

The aim of the paper was to determine agronomical and technological attributes of a range of sugar beet cultivars grown in the Province of Vojvodina which included commercially important cultivars as well as those that have been recently recognized. Another aim of the experiment was to determine the influence of cultivar and locality on the variability in the quality parameters of sugar beet grown under the agro ecological conditions of Vojvodina. In 2009, four small−scale field trials with 15 cultivars were conducted. The trials were planted in a randomized complete block experimental design with four replicates. Chemical analyses of samples and data processing were done according to standard procedures. The trials were harvested at optimal period. in the first half of October.
The mean root yield, averaged over four localities and 15 cultivars, was very high (88.77 t/ha). The contribution of variety and locality to the variations in the yield was 20.16% and 17.78%, respectively. The highest root yield was achieved by cultivar Maurizio (97.50 t/ha) which was triple tolerant to diseases including Rhizoctonia solani. Mean sugar content of the root was also high (17.32% averaged over all localities and cultivars). The influence of cultivar in the variation of this parameter was 11.86% relative and that of locality was 16.89% rel. In average, within all cultivars and localities, the highest root sugar content was recorded for Marcus (18.21%). The mean granulated sugar content, averaged over localities and cultivars, was high (13.631 t/ha) with the influence of cultivar and locality on the variation of results as high as 16.68% rel. i.e. 28.30% rel., respectively. The highest in the granulated sugar content was cultivar Akku with 14.780 t/ha.

INTRODUCTION

A successful production of sugar beet under Vojvodinian agro ecological conditions is not possible without the use of cultivars highly tolerant to Cercospora. Rhizomania and Rhizoctonia solani. The prevalence of Rhizomania and recently Rhizoctonia solani has been rather noticeable in last decade presumably due to continuous sugar beet growing in monoculture or 2-year crop rotation. The exact amount of area infested with the diseases has not been known, but a decrease in the root yields and increased damage coming from root has been evident. According to Bürcky (1995), rapid increase in areas infested with rhizomania was recorded in France. However, in north-west Europe, significant increase in the yield and quality of sugar beet has been observed during the last 20 years due to selection and better agro technical practices (Hoffmann, 2002). The aforementioned facts equally apply to Serbia, too, but only to those producers that follow the latest tehnological recommendations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In 2009, small-scale field trials which included 15 recognized sugar beet cultivars were established. The cultivars were provided from the selection of Strube, Germany. The trials were set at four localities: Bavanište, Bečej, Sombor and Stara Pazova., in the Province of Vojvodina, Serbia, according to randomized complete block pattern with four replications at each location. The size of experimental plots was 30 m2 (10 m x 3 m). Agro technical measures similar to those used in commercial production were applied. Preventive measures against Cercospora beticola included three treatments with usual preparations at all locations. Sugar beet harvest occurred at optimal period, during the first half of October. The size of the basic plot from which the roots were harvested was 4.9 m2.
Chemical analyses of the samples were determined according to standard methods in the laboratories of the Institute for Food Technology in Novi Sad:
  • Sugar content in beet by the method of cold digestion (Milić et al., 1992);
  • Alpha amino nitrogen according to V. Stanek - P. Pavlas (1934/35);
  • Potassium and sodium content by Atomic Absorption Spectrophoto-metry (Milić et al., 1992).
The other quality parameters were calculated according to the following formulas:
  • Sugar content in molasses (SM) (% on root) according to Reinelfeld et al. (1974):
SM = 0.343 x (K+Na)+0.094 x alpha amino N-0.31. where K. Na and alpha amino N are given in mmol/100 g;
  • Sugar utilization (SU) (% on root) according to Reinelfeld et al. (1974):
SU = D-SM-0.6. where D is sugar content (%). SM is sugar content in molasses (%). 0.6 refers to total losses;
  • Thick juice purity (Q) according to Wieninger and Kubadinov (1974):
Q = 99.36-0.1427 x (K+Na+alpha amino N). where K. Na and alpha amino N are given in mmol/100o S;
  • Polarized sugar yield (PSY) (t/ha):
PSY = RY x D. where RY is root yield (t/ha). D is sugar content (%);
  • Granulated sugar yield (GSY) (t/ha):
GSY = RY x SU.
Statistical analysis was performed using two-way ANOVA procedures according to Hadživuković (1973).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The mean root yield, averaged over four localities and 15 cultivars, was very high compared long average value in Vojvodina and amounted to 88.77 t/ha (Table 2). For this parameter, cultivar Maurizio was ranked first with 97.50 t/ha, followed by Prestige (97.01 t/ha), Solea (94.98 t/ha) and others whereas the last was cultivar Kontrola II with 77.84 t/ha. Highest differrence in the root yield within the tested cultivars was 19.66 t/ha or 20.16% rel. Cultivar Marcus was first-ranked regarding the content of sugar in roots (18.21%), followed by Elvis (18.13%), Tibor (17.99%) and others. The worst was Maurizio with 16.05% root sugar content. The highest differrence in this parameter was 2.16% absolute or 11.86% rel. One of the important parameters in sugar beet processing is sugar utilization expressed in percents on beet root. The mean sugar utilization, averaged over localities and cultivars was very high, compared long average value in Vojvodina, 15.37%. Cultivar Markus performed best (16.47%) whereas the poorest was Maurizio with 13.95%. The highest differrence in the sugar utilization was high, 2.52% abs. or 15.30% rel.
The highest thick juice purity was recorded for Markus (94.58) and the lowest for Prestige (92.99). The variability in this parameter was considered high, 1.59. The mean thick juice purity within all cultivars was 93.62.
The content of sugar in molasses, averaged over localities and cultivars, was very low, 1.35%. The lowest content, 1.13%, was determined for cultivar Tibor whereas the highest content was recorded for Prestige, 1.51%. The lowest in the potassium content, averaged over localities, was Markus (17.04 mmol/100oS) and the highest was Sandor (21.37 mmol/100oS). The difference in this parameter between the two extremely ranked cultivars was high, compared long average value in Vojvodina, 4.33 mmol/100oS whereas the mean content was 19.01 mmol/100oS. The mean sodium content in beet, averaged over localities and cultivars, was low, compared long average value in Vojvodina, and amounted to 4.77 mmol/100oS. However, large differrences in this parameter were found within the cultivars: Tibor showed the lowest sodium content of 1.89 mmol/100oS whereas the highest was Maurizio with 9.01 mmol/100oS. The extreme difference in the sodium content amounted to 7.12 mmol/-100oS or, in other words, Tibor contained 4.80 times less sodium than Maurizio. Averaged over localities, Markus was the lowest in the alphaamino nitrogen content, 13.83 mmol/100oS, in contrast to Santino which was the highest with 4.10 mmol/100oS. The difference was 4.10 mmol/100oS and the mean sodium content was 16.46 mmol/100oS. The highest polarized sugar yield was achieved by cultivar Akku (16.475 t/ha) and the lowest by Kontrola II (13.948 t/ha). The extreme differrence within the cultivars was 2.520 t/ha or 15.34% rel. The mean granulated sugar yield, the most important parameter in sugar beet processing, was high compared long average value in Vojvodina (13.631 t/ha). The highest in the granulated sugar yield was cultivar Akku (13.631 t/ha) due to excellent performance regarding other quality parameters. The lowest was Kontrola II with 12.314 t/ha. The highest difference established for this parameter within the tested cultivars was high, 2.466 t/ha or 16.68% rel.

DISCUSSION

High variability in the root yield found within the cultivars harmonizes well with the findings of other authors (Webster et al. 1977, Buddemeger et al. 2004). The extreme difference in the root sugar content between the cultivars was 11.86% rel. and is similar to the results reported by Märländer et al. (1991) and Galattkowski et al. (1994). The variation in this parameter within the tested cultivars is comparable to that reported by Radivojević et al. (1997) in an earlier study. The percentages of sugar utilization were in positive correlation with the root sugar content which is also in agreement with the findings of Radivojević et al. (1998). Values obtained for thick juice purity and sugar content in molasses were found to be in concordance with the conclusions of Bruhns et al. (2004). Kenter et al. (2008) reported similar contents of non-sugar compounds (potassium, sodium, alpha-amino nitrogen) to those found in this study. Higher variation in the polarized sugar yield within the cultivars was in contrast to the findings of Kovačev et al. (2007). The mean yield of granulated sugar was very high, 13.631 t/ha. However, the best performing cultivar regarding this parameter was Akku with 14.780 t/ha and the maximum difference between the first and last ranked cultivar was 2.466 t/ha. Similar results have been reported in other studies (Koch et. al. 2008. Buhre et. al. 2007).

CONCLUSION

On the basis of the results obtained in the small-scale trials with 15 cultivars located on the territory of the Province of Vojvodina, the following conclusions can be drawn:
  • The mean root yield, averaged over localities and cultivars, was very high and reached 88.77 t/ha. The contribution of cultivar and locality to the variation in the yields was 20.16% and 17.78%, respectively. Cultivar Mauricio had the highest root yield.
  • Also, high mean root sugar content was achieved, 17.32% (averaged over localities and cultivars). The influence of cultivar to the variation in the results was 11.86% rel. and locality was 16.89% rel. The highest root sugar content was reported for cultivar Markus (18.21%).
  • The mean values of other pro-cessing parameters were also well positioned i.e. the tested cultivars were of good quality.
  • The granulated sugar yield was very high, 13.631 t/ha. The best per-forming cultivar was Akku (14.780 t/ha) and the poorest was the con-trol cultivar Kontrola II (12.314). The influence of cultivar and locality on the variation in the granulated sugar yield was 16.68% i.e. 28.30%, res-pecttively.
On the basis of the aforementioned results, it is obvious that newly recognized sugar beet cultivars are high yielding and have excellent processing quality. The yields and overall performance reported in this study, and the previous five years, proved that the results achieved in Vojvodina are at comparable level to those reached in the developed countries of west Europe like France, Germany, etc.



Download full article PDF

DOWNLOAD PDF